Euthanasia: cost factor is a worry

National award-winning writer Pinki Virani, who brought the issue of euthanasia to the fore by her petitioning the Supreme Court on behalf of Aruna Shanbaug, is among India’s best-selling authors.

Will The media debate on the Supreme Court’s verdict in the Aruna Shanbaug case has proceeded along predictable lines — the same as in the rest of the world. These are decadeold questions —the right of terminally ill patients and their families to seek a dignified end to the suffering; the distinction between active and passive euthanasia.

Most countries have debated these issues, rejected the idea of active euthanasia and very few have legalized it. The Supreme Court has also played safe by suggesting that ‘passive’ euthanasia can be looked at on a case-bycase basis.

There is, however, a critical linkage which most discussions fail to make, ie, the economic and social dimension. Any debate on euthanasia, which does not take into account the heavily privatized structure of Indian healthcare, is in a sense, incomplete and perhaps, elitist.

Let me begin by saying that many Indian doctors in India have been practicing a form of passive euthanasia for many years, although few are likely to admit it. This may not have ‘legal’ sanction , but it is a practical approach when it involves a terminally ill patient. In some cases, this is based purely on an assessment of the futility of treatment. But often, there is a critical additional factor, which influences the decision of the team treating the patient. This is the cost of treatment. anyone take Aruna’s place? |

  • You may also like

    1. Aruna Shanbaug rape case verdict

      Aruna Shanbaug, raped 37 years ago, restricted to a hospital bed, and in a semi-comatose state, will... More →

    2. CCHF virus | No need to worry about cchf virus | C...

      cchf virus | No need to worry about cchf virus ... More →

    3. PJ Thomas faces criminal conspiracy charges | PJ T...

      PJ Thomas, who was shown the door by the Supreme Court from the post of Central Vigilance Commission... More →

    4. Premananda death news | Premananda passed away | P...

      Premananda, who is serving double life imprisonment for rape... More →